Still, can't wait for 4th ed to come out, yes indeady!
BOOOO! Boo to 4th edition!
I am a second ed. stuck in the mud. The later stuff seems a bit power gamey to me, with all its feats and prestige classes and whatnot.
I've been playing RPG's for a good twenty years (the name I use on this board is that of an old PC of mine) and not once have I felt inclined to worship the devil, not even when I was a player in a long-running game where all the characters were lawful evil devil-worshippers. This is because I know the difference between reality and fiction.
I think that people link D&D with Satanism, because they have never seen anyone engage in either practise. Only the other day, I was asked by a friend "Do you all dress up then?". I think that a lot of people imagine D&D payers gathered around an engraved pentagram, chanting and sacrificing goats. If people knew that all the average game consists of is a bunch of silly sods sat in a room giggling, rolling dice and eating pizza, they would have a lot less problem with it. Actually, the same could probably be said for Satanism!
As for MERP, have you seen Rolemaster? Now there is a system for rules lawyers. Any rule set that expects you to roll for weapon breakage every time you hit is beyond loony. Note that each different weapon has a different breakage chance. Just loony. It did have some good crit's though. My favourite went something like "Foes entire skeleton is shattered, he is reduced to a gelatinous pulp. Try a spatula."
Mutate and Survive