|
Register | Sign In |
|
QuickSearch
Thread ▼ Details |
Member (Idle past 96 days) Posts: 10333 From: London England Joined: |
Thread Info
|
|
|
Author | Topic: Atheism Examined | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
nator Member (Idle past 2200 days) Posts: 12961 From: Ann Arbor Joined: |
quote: I feel this way about myself, too, but I rarely talk to anybody else about it.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
purpledawn Member (Idle past 3488 days) Posts: 4453 From: Indiana Joined: |
quote:If you know an atheist, what specifically in their actions makes you think they are acting like a child whose parents are on vacation? Do you feel they go through stop signs or red lights when no cars or police are present? Once we become adults and support ourselves we no longer have that mindset. Atheist would function at the adult level which is what we are supposed to do. Why does someone believe you when you say there are four billion stars, but check when you say the paint is wet?
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
purpledawn Member (Idle past 3488 days) Posts: 4453 From: Indiana Joined: |
quote:IMO, religion should have matured to the point of helping people understand the spirituality that you speak of. Unfortunately they got stuck in the past. I feel that spiritually many have matured away from religion. Those who were religious and then went atheist. I do think there are people who are rebelling against their religion and aren't maturing spiritually. They believe but are fighting against it instead of working through it. Maybe they need a support group for that. I do agree that the sprituality without the relgious baggage allows one to be more centered. Why does someone believe you when you say there are four billion stars, but check when you say the paint is wet?
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Phat Member Posts: 18354 From: Denver,Colorado USA Joined: Member Rating: 1.0 |
Straggler writes: Thanks, Straggler...here is Synopsis # II:
I am also very grateful for your synopsis as there are some long posts and a lot to read. Synopsis useful Straggler writes: Speaking to you as a Christian, I can only encourage you to be as honest with yourself as you possibly can! Many of our new converts don't really understand the faith and belief that they have taken on! They nevertheless go out and try and engage in mental logic battles with other people whom they don't even take the time to try and get to know.
I cannot believe your personal God by definition and have been given no reason to believe in my own. Straggler writes: Not only that, but an atheist can be someone who never felt compelled to give the matter a second thought. To the atheist, there is nothing to reject and nothing to conclude. They simply move on with their life and do whatever it is that they fancy. They are no more moral than I am, nor any less.
To me - as stated elsewhere - an atheist is someone who has consciously concluded that there are no gods.Straggler writes: Faith is an everyday phenomenon. I sat in the chair that I am in without testing it to see if it could hold me. I had faith that it indeed could. My faith was based on the rationality of prior experience and the knowledge of the strength of wood.
I would say I am pro rational thought rather than anti faith as such (just to be positive ) but in practice they probably amount to the same thing.bluegenes writes: Hardly, Sir! No more than I should renounce my beliefs. We are here to debate each other...not convert each other!
So should the atheists participating in this thread renounce their atheism? I CANT writes: Do you know what a Christian is? You already blew it by attempting to tell us what an atheist is. That would be like me attempting to tell a bunch of scientists what a scientist is. As I have read this thread it seems no one knows what an atheist isand I know for a fact no one knows what a Christian is from all the posts I have read. Religion and a Christian are two totally different things. I CANT writes: What if Jesus comes back as a Muslim? What if Jesus comes back as an atheist?? How much will it take to surprise us? Do any of us really know anything profound??
I have an atheist friend in the Cayman Islands who I have known since 1989, He told me I was going to be surprised when I died and found out that it was over and that was all there was to it (life). I came back with, How can I be surprised if that is all there is to it? On the other hand if you die and find out there is a God you will be the one surprised.I CANT writes: You seem awfully certain! I believe that you are right, but I have a question. Can you assure any one of us that we either do or do not know your God? If I were an atheist, would you consider it your goal to get me to meet Him or would you be friends with me anyway...kinda like your Cayman Island buddy?
I can assure you Hitler did not know my God. anastasia writes: Keyword: IF. Keep in mind, however, that it is not necessary to believe anything in order for reality to be true. An atheist may declare that reality is in no need of belief in order to be proven--that reality simply is.
I can choose to be atheist if I want to at any time. If I can't, that means I really believe something.Crashfrog writes: I think that her point was that since you said that you used to be Christian, you surely could again be so. Some of us never throw away our old emotional baggage. We are spiritual packrats! I don't believe in God. Therefore I'm no lapsed Christian. *Phat rummages through his hall closet looking for any old deities he no longer uses...*
Crashfrog writes: So in essence you cant necessarily see what you imagine. I think I see your point!
The choice I made was to follow the evidence. I can imagine evidence that would change my mind, but I haven't seen it yet.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Brian Member (Idle past 4990 days) Posts: 4659 From: Scotland Joined: |
Not only that, but an atheist can be someone who never felt compelled to give the matter a second thought. To the atheist, there is nothing to reject and nothing to conclude. They simply move on with their life and do whatever it is that they fancy. They are no more moral than I am, nor any less. Phat, every single thing in the above quote is incorrect. Declaring yourself an atheist is a conscious decision, if you havent given 'it a second thought' you are not an atheist. An atheist is based on faith, how can you take a stance on something if you haven't given it a second thought? Atheists reject theism for many reasons, have a read over the thread again for some of them. We also have many conclusions as well, for example I conclude that anyone who believes in God has something missing in their lives. What do you mean by 'doing whatever they want'? No one can go about doing whatever they want, society would be chaotic if this is true. Finally, atheists are certainly more moral than Christians. Christians only do good deeds because they want a reward from the big guy in the sky. Atheists do not believe in the big guy in the sky so we do good deeds out of the goodness of our hearts, thus we are more moral. Brian.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
ICANT Member Posts: 6769 From: SSC Joined: Member Rating: 1.7 |
I CANT writes: As I have read this thread it seems no one knows what an atheist is and I know for a fact no one knows what a Christian is from all the posts I have read. Religion and a Christian are two totally different things. Do you know what a Christian is? You already blew it by attempting to tell us what an atheist is. That would be like me attempting to tell a bunch of scientists what a scientist is. When did an observation become attempting to define something? Phat please read post 167
I CANT writes: I can assure you Hitler did not know my God. You seem awfully certain! I believe that you are right, but I have a question. Can you assure any one of us that we either do or do not know your God? If I were an atheist, would you consider it your goal to get me to meet Him or would you be friends with me anyway...kinda like your Cayman Island buddy? Phat I would love you just as I do all my friends yes including those that do no believe like I do, of which many are atheist. On Hitler I would say I am 99% sure.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
ringo Member (Idle past 443 days) Posts: 20940 From: frozen wasteland Joined: |
ICANT writes: On Hitler I would say I am 99% sure. I am 98% sure that you and Hitler will wind up in the same place. And I am 83% sure that Coke is better than Pepsi. Empty opinions are easy, aren't they? I am also 99% sure that "your God" doesn't exist. Does that make me an atheist? Help scientific research in your spare time. No cost. No obligation. Join the World Community Grid with Team EvC
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Jon Inactive Member |
My faith was based on the rationality of prior experience and the knowledge of the strength of wood. That's not faith. That's a conclusion based on rationally reasoned past experiences and your knowledge of the "strength of wood." This all requires actual evidence, which you have--past experience, knowledge of wood, etc.--something faith requires none of.
We are here to debate each other...not convert each other! We are? Oh... shame?
*Phat rummages through his hall closet looking for any old deities he no longer uses...* Perhaps you can consult them for debt relief too? Jonicus Edited by Jns, : YEEHOO!-- AH! :-) Edited by Jns, : Oopsicus
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
anastasia Member (Idle past 5984 days) Posts: 1857 From: Bucks County, PA Joined: |
purpledawn writes: If you know an atheist, what specifically in their actions makes you think they are acting like a child whose parents are on vacation? I don't think that. I was talking about how religious people might mis-conceive atheism by thinking about it from within their own set-up. And I don't mean all religious people, but maybe those who take part in these polls about trusting atheists.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
anastasia Member (Idle past 5984 days) Posts: 1857 From: Bucks County, PA Joined: |
Brian writes: Declaring yourself an atheist is a conscious decision, if you havent given 'it a second thought' you are not an atheist. An atheist is based on faith, how can you take a stance on something if you haven't given it a second thought? I have noticed that there are two stances amoung atheists. One is that atheism is faith based, the other is that it is the absence of faith in gods. I still suggest coinage f a new term to denote these positions, rather than the all confusing 'agnostic'.
Atheists reject theism for many reasons, have a read over the thread again for some of them. We also have many conclusions as well, for example I conclude that anyone who believes in God has something missing in their lives. And theists conclude the same, which is why this is not the place for competition, but definition. Maybe part of your def for atheism is 'someone who feels that theists are missing something' but that would be a silly way to characterize motives for theism, and it goes back to the major similarity. Both theists and atheists believe that they have 'found' something. It's about what works for the individual. Any other competitive debate of this nature is merely the same old 'is what we find true, and can we prove it?' argument. None of us can, so there is no reason for any uppity high-ground position.
Finally, atheists are certainly more moral than Christians. Christians only do good deeds because they want a reward from the big guy in the sky. Atheists do not believe in the big guy in the sky so we do good deeds out of the goodness of our hearts, thus we are more moral. This is your favorite belief. It is just a messy as saying Christians are more moral. You want to be talking about motives, about who has better motives, and not about who is 'more moral'. You are misrepresenting the christian position on doing good, so honestly, you can't be atheist because you think its better than something else. It has to fit you, and it will be better FOR YOU, but you have no knowledge to say that any view is better because none of us do. We all have more in common than not.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
anastasia Member (Idle past 5984 days) Posts: 1857 From: Bucks County, PA Joined: |
nator writes: I feel this way about myself, too, but I rarely talk to anybody else about it. I find myself wondering, and this is probably so not OT, whether the spirituality that you speak of is not based on some version of belief in the unseen. Many spiritualities could easily turn into pantheism, for example, or something similar. This is not an accusation. But from the word itself, spirit, there is a connotation of the unseen. There are spiritualities which don't require a higher power as in a god. It would be interesting to find out what spirituality means to other people, although not this thread. Maybe atheism is something to do with disillusionment in organized religion, or in the specific xian God. Not for everyone, but some. I can see that a certain representation of God is not for everyone, and that organized religion can hold one back in discovery of God. I don't think there is an intent to limit God, but somewhere along the way the concept of the Christian God became very fabricated in appearance. Anyway, I am sure that you are aware of alternatives in faith even if some are not. I merely speculate that some proclaimed atheists are latching onto a word that sounds to them like a good landing-place for people who have no denomination. Not in this forum I think, because all here are educated about alternatives. Edited by anastasia, : No reason given.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Brian Member (Idle past 4990 days) Posts: 4659 From: Scotland Joined: |
I have noticed that there are two stances amoung atheists. One is that atheism is faith based, the other is that it is the absence of faith in gods. Both stances are faith based. Declaring that you do not believe in gods is a faith based stance
I still suggest coinage f a new term to denote these positions, rather than the all confusing 'agnostic'. If we took of our faith hat, then we really should ALL be agnostics.
And theists . . . . . high-ground position. These example were just to demonstrate to Phat the errors in his thinking.
This is your favorite belief. It isn’t a belief, it is a fact.
It is just a messy as saying Christians are more moral. But they aren’t.
You want to be talking about motives, about who has better motives, and not about who is 'more moral'. Motives and morality are inseparable.
You are misrepresenting the christian position on doing good, No I am not. Tell me this, do you want to be Saved? Brian
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
crashfrog Member (Idle past 1498 days) Posts: 19762 From: Silver Spring, MD Joined: |
When you say "faith", what are you talking about?
Faith is such a funny thing. So pernicious that even the most evidence-based, reasonable, rational conclusion can be described as taking something on "faith."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Brian Member (Idle past 4990 days) Posts: 4659 From: Scotland Joined: |
I have recently, thanks to a colleague, begun reading a few of C. S. Lewis’ books, and have found him to be a very readable author.
I just flicked the book open to chapter two of his ”Reflections on the Psalms’, and found the following very apt information. “ IF THERE (sic) is any thought at which a Christian trembles it is the thought of God’s “judgement”. The “Day” of Judgement is “that day of wrath, that dreadful day”. We pray for God to deliver us “in the hour of death and at the day of Judgement”. Christian art and literature for centuries have depicted its terrors. This note in Christianity certainly goes back to the teachings of Our Lord Himself; especially to the terrible parable of the Sheep and the Goats. This can leave no conscience untouched, for in it the “Goats” are condemned entirely for their sins of omission; as if to make us fairly sure that the heaviest charge against us turns not upon the things he (sic) has done but on those he (sic) never did - perhaps never dreamed of doing. Pretty big coincidence opening the book at that page. But comforting to know that the great Christian scholar agrees with me that Christians are a selfish lot. Brian
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Brian Member (Idle past 4990 days) Posts: 4659 From: Scotland Joined: |
So pernicious that even the most evidence-based, reasonable, rational conclusion can be described as taking something on "faith." Yes this is pretty much what faith is. Regarding the existence of God, it is an entity that we cannot test for, thus we can only affirm or deny belief in this entity. Atheists don't believe that there is any convincing argument or evidence for the existence of gods, but since we cannot test for it, we need to have faith that our conclusions are accurate. Personally, I have concluded that gods are the invention of the human mind. I have very good reasons for believing this, but outside the realm of faith, I really need to be honest and say that I could be wrong. If a theist stepped outside their realm of faith they would need to conclude the same as I have. However, I have chosen my personal faith as atheism, and it is as much a faith as Islam, Judaism, or any other faith. Brian.
|
|
|
Do Nothing Button
Copyright 2001-2023 by EvC Forum, All Rights Reserved
Version 4.2
Innovative software from Qwixotic © 2024