I must say on a simple inspection I thought that the use of papers from 1976 questionable. In any developing field many 20 year old papers are going to be seriously out of date.
And you certainly wouldn't get that essay published now - the "missing neutrinos" problem has been solved - a result that was widely publicised. Davies doesn't even mention the solution as a possibility although I am sure that it was proposed and I beleive that it was under active investigation even at the time of writing.