I was trying to be a jazz trumpeter before I realized that it would undermine my first goal in life which was raising a family. I went into CS instead which was my second love. I still like to dream about gigging and being a part of that scene though.
I guess my point about the topic is that maybe the question should be phrased such that it is a little less presumptuous.
Is there a fatal flaw in Darwinian evolutionary, materialistic and naturalistic logic and if so what is it?
Which would have the net effect of not setting off your opposition's BS sirens.