quote:
The main question of the OP is the thread title, "Is there Biblical support for the concept of 'Original Sin'?" Romans 5 is part of the Bible. So if Paul teaches the concept in Rom 5, the answer to this question must be "yes", whether we agree with Paul's reasoning or not. Our agreement or disagreement with Paul is irrelevant to the question of what he teaches.
But is that what Paul was teaching?
The Doctrine of Original Sin is another case of pagan philosophy creeping into Christianity.
The Origin and History of the Doctrine of Original Sin
Were the authors of the
proof texts used to prove the Doctrine of Original Sin actually presenting that belief?
To interpret the phrase "made sinners" to mean that men are born sinners and become sinners involuntarily and necessarily by receiving a sinful nature from Adam, is a forced and inconsistent interpretation of this passage; for this passage not only says that all men are "made sinners" because of Adam's transgression, it also says that all men are "made righteous" by the obedience of Christ, and that the free gift of life "came upon all men" by Christ Jesus. So, for the advocates of the doctrine of original sin to arbitrarily give to the phrases "made sinners" and "came upon all men" the meaning of physical force and physical necessity when these phrases refer to Adam's sin, without giving the same meaning to them when they refer to Christ's righteousness, is once again an example of a forced and inconsistent interpretation dictated by a prepossessed belief in the doctrine of original sin.
Paul did not teach that men are "made righteous" involuntarily through Christ, nor did he teach that men are "made sinners" involuntarily through Adam.
To be able to go against God's command, Adam already had a sinful nature, IOW, he was capable of disobedience. Even if we have a sinful nature (evil inclination), it doesn't mean we have no control over our actions. God even told Cain he could control the evil inclinations.
Genesis 4:6-7
Then the Lord said to Cain, "Why are you angry? Why is your face downcast? If you do what is right, will you not be accepted? But if you do not do what is right, sin is crouching at your door; it desires to have you, but you must master it.
Of course we have to remember that sin is an action and not something that exists on it own.
Bible authors like personification.