Hi Jeremy,
The "ludicrosity" can't change unless there's somebody to stand up and address specific points. Passing the buck isn't going to get anybody anywhere. I invite you to engate some users in an honest debate on the issues, and see where it goes, before leave.
I agree with you that there is a lot of "speaking to the choir." But "real discussion" necessitates a debate partner. Only someone like yourself can provide that.
And, welcome to EvC!
Ben