I like your thread and think it can make for interesting subject, but at the same time I agree with AdminTL that we might find ourselves sparring over semantics and the definition of "living," rather than actually discussing much of the premise you have presented.
Nonetheless, I say its promotable insofar that it doesn't focus too heavily on the semantical issues.
But I will let TL handle it as a courtesy of not stepping on his toes. I'm just chiming in on TL's request for input.