General discussion of moderation procedures - Part 7

I see a vicious circle coming up here. There is thus no means by which one can circumvent the establishment (if one exists) and no way to show there is no establishment. Hmmm Which could vary depending on all sorts of things, nothing of which has to do with the science involved. Define 'significant' in some non self-fulfilling prophecy manner. I'm sure some of the lumninaries here have debated him in the past. Neither do I cast aside their reticence - I have seen the worst of John. But the sheer silence from those once so authoritative on the issue in general forum strikes me as remarkable. Truly remarkable.Edited by AdminJar, : not a discussion thread

Sorry Jar. Fair point.

I'm kind of troubled by that myself. And have been from the start. It has become a parody at this stage.But what also troubles me is that there hasn't been much in the way of truly penetrating questions. The PEH is there. If NeoD is King then I would have imagined there to be a string of approaches that would cut through the hot air and reveal PEH to be a sham - if that is what it is.Folk seem to scuttle off after a post or two due to the ridicule. But under normal EvC circumstance they never do that. They ask a question that cuts to the core. Something that silences the ridiculing opponantIt just hasn't happened. And its not like PEH fits my own views in anycase. John has Creos just as much in his sights as he does the EvosNo one has unpacked the fallacy behind PEH - if they believe it to be fallacious. John ridicules for sure. But he is also ridiculed. No clues as to PEH veracity thereIt seems to me that PEH sits there unaffected by it all. Amongst all the noise all I hear is silence.

I think Pink Sasquatch is doing quiet nicely without my assistance thanks all the same (if the truth be known, Science fora are useful only for getting my toenails clipped - I know when I'm beat once the skin starts getting removed)I await John with interest. This is more like it.Edited by iano, : No reason given.