But you did say that you would consider your "different model" as to be "supernatural," did you not?
Buz, perhaps a remedial reading course is in order.
Percy said that if he say the cup come together in a time reversed dropping and breaking it would seem supernatural to him BUT it isn't automatically so since it doesn't seem to violate the time symmetric laws of physics.
To be simpler: Percy was pointing out that even something that he might think was supernatural doesn't have to be.
If you can't get the meaning out of what you read you are in even worse shape than I thought. This isn't the first time, not by a long shot, that you've had this problem.