The "dumb brute" view of Neanderthals is not one that I think holds much sway among scientists. According to what I've read, Neanderthals possessed similar intelligence (larger brains on average, but that's not necessarily a good indication of intelligence) and technology equivalent to that possessed by modern humans at the time.
slevesque writes:
For my part I think neanderthals were pretty much humans
That's what being of the Homo genus means.
slevesque writes:
but with overly atheltic genes and capacities
Well, they were stockier and their ribs flared out, making their torso more of a barrel shape. Their skulls differed significantly in shape from any modern human race, with a pronounced brow ridge and lack of a protruding chin etc.
Besides a slightly different anatomy, I think a Neanderthal would have quite a lot in common with us. I'd be most interested in whether it could speak like modern humans do.
I say go ahead with the experiment, if it can be done! Imagine what we would stand to learn about human evolution by bringing back our closest cousin species.
Respectfully,
-Meldinoor