Where you married before you where atheist? Or was it just she and her family that wanted it?
I'm a strong believer that marriage isn't just a personal covenant, it's a social one. So largely the tenor of our wedding - officiated by a pastor in our college's chapel - was because we knew that stuff was important to our families.
If it had been just us we were worrying about we would have gone to a justice of the peace and have done with it, or for that matter, we might not have even bothered in the first place.
But I had no objection to a religious ceremony, because the wedding isn't just a party for her and I - it's a social obligation. In return, we get social approval of our unity. And it wasn't like the Methodists are anything but low-key Protestants, anyway.
There wasn't much religious stuff that I had to do.