This is not a thread to criticize moderation or to suggest that people leave this forum.
This comment from obvious Child on
Advice
I've seen that before. I've even seen a forum where the creationist admin banned a bunch of people because they were making bantha hash out of his creationist members and his member were resorting to personal insults. Sad isn't it?
One of the reasons I like this site is because it is moderated to that trolls\spam\etc behavior is minimized. I find the moderation here is not biased in the way I have seen on other sites, however I understand that it is not always easy to see who is at fault when things get out of hand if you are not involved in the thread.
I've seen references to other sites and the differences in moderation.
What I propose is a listing of other sites that people have been at, with an evaluation of their benefits and liabilities.
Other ones I have posted on are:
(1) AOL Message Board
Creation vs. Evolution - a branch of a message board, originally run by netscape before it was acquired by AOL. The board is not moderated at all, leaving anarchy in control.
- the reply functions allow some formating and you can include links and pictures. It is NOT WYSIWYG, so if you paste into the reply window it may look okay in pasted form, but be completely weird when posted. There is no "quote" function, and there is also no post preview function.
- with no moderation, the only recourse is to ignore people that engage in bad or abusive language or disruptive behavior. The board does have an "ignore author" function where you can have the messages filtered so that certain posters are not displayed when you sign on. This works as self-moderation.
- there is no thread control to stay on topic, so you can get a lot of "chat" posts and topics can get buried or so changed that the topic title has no bearing on the topic under discussion.
- if you don't like moderation, or feel that moderation is always biased against you, you may like this site, as the only control on the board is the "ignore author" function.
- at the moment there are not many active posters.
It is now run by AOL and you need either an old netscape username, an AIM username or an AOL username to sign on.
(2) Herb Allure
Creation and Evolution - a side branch of a forum dedicated to (selling and) discussing the benefits of herbal cures, with a heavy creationist bias, with the owner being an Old Earth Creationists (OEC), but several YEC's posting. Not heavily moderated, certainly the creationists are not moderated for using abusive language.
- the reply functions allow some formating and you can include links and pictures. It is similar to this board using UBcode in the reply windows but with some differences ([image] instead of [img]) There is a "quote" function, and there is also a post preview function. The reply window is even smaller than the old one here.
- with light and biased moderation, the only recourse is to ignore people that engage in bad or abusive language or disruptive behavior. Bad mouthing herbal cures will attract more moderation than any other behavior.
- there is no thread control to stay on topic, so you can get a lot of "chat" posts and topics can get buried or so changed that the topic title has no bearing on the topic under discussion.
- if you feel that moderation here is always biased against creationists you may like this site.
- at the moment there are not many active C/E posters.
You need to register a username to post.
Neither of these come up to the level of expertize or depth of knowledge on various topics that I find here at EvC.
So what other boards have people here been to and what are they like?
Enjoy.
Edited by RAZD, : grammar
we are limited in our ability to understand
by our ability to understand
RebelAAmericanOZen[Deist
... to learn ... to think ... to live ... to laugh ...
to share.
• • • Join the effort to solve medical problems, AIDS/HIV, Cancer and more with Team EvC! (click) • • •