Cold Foreign Object writes:
How could both of you guys miss the answer that was clearly posted in the message replied to?
Actually, I was answering to post 143 http://
EvC Forum: Dawkins - 'The God Delusion' -->
EvC Forum: Dawkins - 'The God Delusion' . The one you made before that link. You can see the post being replied to on mine, and the timing (we were both writing at the same time). So, in the post I missed while writing, you make it clear that you are talking about "the God of St. Paul".
While that answers the "which God" part of my questioning, it doesn't answer the rest.
bluegenes writes:
Which God? Consider all the many Gods that have been invented in many different cultures. You write about "God", singular, so it appears that you only believe in one of them. Is your disbelief in all the others an example of delusion in operation?
Can you remember choosing which one to believe in? Can you honestly say that you were not emulating people around you?
For some time down the thread, you seem to be questioning Richard Dawkins' use of the word delusion in relation to belief in a God. Then you claim that your God sows delusions in certain people. What I'd like to know is how you've decided that belief in your particular God is not a delusion, because surely you must share my opinion that believers in Gods other than your preferred one must be suffering from delusions.
I'd also like to know how you made the choice of which God to believe in, how old you were when you made it, how you made the decision, whether you lied to yourself in the process, and, most of all, I'd like to see if you can answer these questions without practising self-delusion.
If you cannot, I think it's a point for Mr. Dawkins.