I attempted to read his book and found it annoying, insulting, and at times illogical - and to a great extent I agree with him. (So I didn't get very far... feel free to dismiss me as you like).
I'm about 2/3 of the way through but don't find it any of those things. Perhaps you and I could discuss it? (separately from loonies who haven't even read the thing).
I have to agree with you. I'd like to see a real discussion of the book (by those who have read it ). Perhaps Percy or Jazzns would like to tear it up paragraph by paragraph? Maybe in a thread per chapter format?
I'd enjoy being forced to reread it with a more critical eye helping to look at it more closely.