Percy, what I envision and it was my post is we limit the topic to criticisms of evolution and some rebuttals which may demand alternative answers, but are more focussed on defending evolution, not make the thread about the different forms of creationism and ID except as they arise in the thread.
So the evo posts a critique of ToE, and I and/or some non-evos respond with the arguments for ToE. That way the topic is about ToE and various criticims of it.
I am not that interested in attacking YECism, except in this context, and partly because I don't know enough about it.
The thread is meant to be about how well non-evos understand ToE, and how well evos understand the criticisms of ToE, not necessarily all the various models out there in toto.
This message has been edited by randman, 08-22-2005 08:18 PM