|
Register | Sign In |
|
QuickSearch
Thread ▼ Details |
|
|
Author | Topic: Is Abiogenesis a fact? | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SuperNintendo Chalmers Member (Idle past 5833 days) Posts: 772 From: Bartlett, IL, USA Joined: |
Hi everyone, this is my first shot at a new topic.... so don't be too harsh on me!
My question is can we consider Abiogenesis a fact?Evolution is both a fact and a theory. Fact - Living things change over time The theory of evolution is our attempt to explain the process behing this. So can we say: Fact - There used to be no life on earth. There is now life on earth. Therefore life arose from non-life. The theory of abiogenesis is how we attempt to explain the process. I am not asking if the theory of abiogenesis is true, only whether we can consider it a fact that abiogenesis happened (although we could certainly discuss abiogenesis). Also note, even if we consider it a fact that abiogenesis happened it does not preclude a god or god(s) causing it to happpen. So can we consider abiogensis a factual occurence based on available evidence?
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
AdminAsgara Administrator (Idle past 2302 days) Posts: 2073 From: The Universe Joined: |
Thread moved here from the Proposed New Topics forum.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Minnemooseus Member Posts: 3941 From: Duluth, Minnesota, U.S. (West end of Lake Superior) Joined: Member Rating: 10.0 |
I think I can accept your "fact" of abiogenesis, if you would include the possibility of life having come from outer space as being one of the possible processes of abiogenesis.
Fact of Abiogenesis - Life did have an initial occurance on Earth" Because of the terminal uncertainties about the very ealiest lifeforms, I question if the collected knowledge about abiogenesis does or ever can be truly elevated to theory status. I personally would prefer sticking to "Hypothesis of Abiogenesis" (HoA). One of the competing hypothesies of abiogenesis could be "Godly creation". Another could be "introduced from space". And so forth. And I don't think you're going to come anywhere close to "proving" any of them. Moose
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SuperNintendo Chalmers Member (Idle past 5833 days) Posts: 772 From: Bartlett, IL, USA Joined: |
I think I can accept your "fact" of abiogenesis, if you would include the possibility of life having come from outer space as being one of the possible processes of abiogenesis. Fact of Abiogenesis - Life did have an initial occurance on Earth" Good point there. I hadn't even considered an extraterrestrial source. I guess that is certainly a possibility (reminds of one of my favorite episodes of Star Trek - TNG)..... I guess the fact of abiogenesis would state. First part - "There was originally no life on earth" - In other words if you go back in time far enough at some point there is no life on earth. For example, let's say there is no life on earth for the frist 2 billion years (just an example, not a claim). Second part - "There is life on earth now"... Basically at some point in earth's history life appeared and there had never been terrestrial life before that. We may never have a theory of abiogenesis... who knows. (personally, I think our best bet would be to get really lucky and discover another earth like planet very early in it's development cycle). However, if we are even going to try and figure out how life arose I think it's very important that we have evidence that there was once no life on earth and there is now. Question: Do we have enough evidence to know that there was origninally no life on earth. in other words Start condition = no life.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Discreet Label Member (Idle past 5063 days) Posts: 272 Joined: |
As to the question of there being enough information to deduce whether there was no life on earth originally...I thought there was.
And the way the evidence was indicated was through geology, i believe. Right now my information is a little sketchy its been a couple million words reading since i last read about life on earth earlier. talk origins had a few faqs in regards to it, one of them indicated that oxygen dependant life had not occured yet because earth was a heavily reducing atmosphere. and when photosynthesis started occuring is when we started moving toward a more oxidizing atmoshphere. And the evidence that photosynthesis wasn't present the entire time was because of thick bands of oxidized iron compounds IIRC. Any oxygen that was created through photosynthesis pretty quickly bound up with iron which started forming thick layers on the crust. Err...so the heavy bands of iron kind of indicate that start of oxygen type life (i'm not so sure about the not so oxygen kind of life that exists near thermal vents though)
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Nuggin Member (Idle past 2492 days) Posts: 2965 From: Los Angeles, CA USA Joined: |
Sorta off topic kinda but...
Don't know if you guys saw it but scientists have found bacteria that rely on photosynthesis at the bottom of the ocean. Apparently bubbles emerging from the vents produce small bursts of light when they collapse. It's not much, but enough for these deep critters to get by. Kinda makes you think about whether life started on the surface and worked its way down, or if life maybe started deep in the Earths mantle and has been working its way up and out.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Modulous Member Posts: 7801 From: Manchester, UK Joined: |
I think we can safely say that there was a time when there was no life. From that no life, sprang life. As stated earlier it could be theogenesis or xenogenesis but ultimately it is always abiogenesis. So yes, I'll go with abiogenesis being a fact, however there is no explanation for it, so no 'theory', just a few varying hypotheses.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Parasomnium Member Posts: 2224 Joined: |
If it's life that came from outer space, then the question of how life arose is still unanswered. The question should not be how life arose on earth - although that is of course our immediate concern - but how life arose in the universe.
Did you know that most of the time your computer is doing nothing? What if you could make it do something really useful? Like helping scientists understand diseases? Your computer could even be instrumental in finding a cure for HIV/AIDS. Wouldn't that be something? If you agree, then join World Community Grid now and download a simple, free tool that lets you and your computer do your share in helping humanity. After all, you are part of it, so why not take part in it?
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
RAZD Member (Idle past 1404 days) Posts: 20714 From: the other end of the sidewalk Joined:
|
Good point there. I hadn't even considered an extraterrestrial source. I guess that is certainly a possibility (reminds of one of my favorite episodes of Star Trek - TNG)..... Where I stand on this is pretty well covered by (not to toot my horn but)http://EvC Forum: RAZD - Building Blocks of Life It seems to me that the universe is seeded with the stuff necessary for the beginning of life, so all that is needed is a good enough "crucible" - a "habitizable" planet. Certainly the earth was very different at the beginning of life than it is now, and early life is responsible for that change. It is also likely that we will never know the exact moment, seeing as the oldest rocks we can find that have not been transformed already have evidence of rather advanced life - complete cells. Before that all we have is evidence that the planet was not habitable - according to out understanding of life - due to rampant volcanic activity. we are limited in our ability to understand by our ability to understand RebelAAmerican.Zen[Deist
... to learn ... to think ... to live ... to laugh ... to share.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SuperNintendo Chalmers Member (Idle past 5833 days) Posts: 772 From: Bartlett, IL, USA Joined: |
Thanks everyone, I figured that what you all replied was the case, but it's always interesting to hear other points of view.
I think maybe I chose the wrong word (abiogenesis). What I was getting at, is if it was safe to assume that start condition earth = no life. (of course current condition earth = life)... Even though this may seem obvious to all of us... It seems important to me at least, that we are fairly sure this is a valid assumption (of course the alternative would be that life has always existed on earth, which I would agree seems impossible).
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
LinearAq Member (Idle past 4675 days) Posts: 598 From: Pocomoke City, MD Joined: |
In the OP, Mini_Ditka writes:
From the Christian Apologetics site - http://www.carm.org/evolution/evoterms.htm :
My question is can we consider Abiogenesis a fact?quote: From the Talk.Origins Archive - 29+ Evidences for Macroevolution: Glossary
quote: From these definitions, I would say that you are asking about life from non-life rather than if the Martians left their DNA while copulating in the ocean before they left for another galaxy. There are a number of experiments going on concerning this subject. Despite some promising results, I don't think that the scientific community at large is stating that abiogenesis is a fact.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
LinearAq Member (Idle past 4675 days) Posts: 598 From: Pocomoke City, MD Joined: |
Even though this may seem obvious to all of us... It seems important to me at least, that we are fairly sure this is a valid assumption (of course the alternative would be that life has always existed on earth, which I would agree seems impossible). You seem to have overlooked the chance that a god had a hand/tenticle/noodly appendage in it. Many assume that abiogenesis means that there was no supernatural force acting on the chemicals that clumped together. So, gods causing the initial lifeform could be an option. Aliens too...but you put that in with abiogenesis for some unfathomable reason. edited to get my quote box right This message has been edited by LinearAq, 12-29-2005 02:56 PM
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SuperNintendo Chalmers Member (Idle past 5833 days) Posts: 772 From: Bartlett, IL, USA Joined: |
From these definitions, I would say that you are asking about life from non-life rather than if the Martians left their DNA while copulating in the ocean before they left for another galaxy. There are a number of experiments going on concerning this subject. Despite some promising results, I don't think that the scientific community at large is stating that abiogenesis is a fact. I'm not referring to any hypothesis about how life arose from non-life. I am simply saying that originally there was no life on earth and now there is. How this arose is entirely another question. Could abiogensis, xenogenesis even theogenesis. Look at evolution. There is the fact of evolution and the theory. FACT - evolution occurs i.e. living things change over time The theory is our explanation of this process. same type of thing here.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
LinearAq Member (Idle past 4675 days) Posts: 598 From: Pocomoke City, MD Joined: |
Ok...
Then all you are asking is whether life has been on earth back through infinity past. I would say...hmmmmm...nope! Since the Earth is 4.5 billion years old and the universe seems to be only ~14 billion years old, then inifinity past for life on earth is pretty much out of the question.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
NosyNed Member Posts: 8996 From: Canada Joined: |
This is something that everyone here can agree with.
There was a time when there was no life on earth. It arose from inorganic matter. We all agree. There are some minor difficulties with getting agreement on the details. One group says that a God took dust and made it alive -- no details are given as to how this occured. Another group says that life arose as a combination of inorgainic chemicals --- very limited details are hypothesized. One side knows it doesn't know the details; the other seems convinced it does but has never offered any.
|
|
|
Do Nothing Button
Copyright 2001-2023 by EvC Forum, All Rights Reserved
Version 4.2
Innovative software from Qwixotic © 2024