Fair enough. I'll also add that after more digging I found a very comprehensive criticism of
Lies, Damned Lies, Statistics, and Probability of
Abiogenesis Calculations on a creationist-dominant debate board:
Bot Verification
I'll be the first to admit that I don't have the PHD in biochem to form an original opinion about the science behind these claims, but I do generally trust the mainstream scientific community because of their obvious contributions to society. So it really comes down to an issue of which "experts" each person puts his trust in.
I also read some criticism that this board was too evolution-biased and self-affirming. Maybe some people from here should post on
The Evolution Fairytale and vice versa for more lively discourse.