Cue scene of an obnoxiously snarky kid endlessly asking "Why?"...
straggler writes:
So a question like: Why are plants green? - Is a perfectly legitimate scientific question.
Why? ...endlessly.......
How are plants green? doesn't make nearly as much sense as a question does it?
No, it wouldn't make a similar level of sense! However, TO ME, the phrase that makes the far
less sense is the
Why one, not the
How one. In fact, in my opinion -
How blows the
Why form out of the water. The "How are plants green?" choice in english to pursue this inquiry in science is VASTLY SUPERIOR than "Why are plants green." It immediately directs the investigators to the right things to describe & explain & support with objective scientific evidence. No one pursuing the
How question would ever suggest it would be answered with the likes of "because God wanted them to be green."
I might modestly suggest that the word "why" be shunned from scientific literature in a similar manner to the way the word "faith" would be. It wont happen, but to continue to leave it in leaves lots of room for misunderstanding. Exhibit A: our friend Dawn Bertot.
This may be a major contribution to the difficulty of people brought up in some kind of religion to understand evolution and TOE.
- xongsmith, 5.7d