Peanut Gallery for the Faith/Jazzns Great Debate

Thats for the commentary Percy. Also thanks to JonF for all the good examples of non-flat disconformities. I knew they existed but just didn't know what magic words to type into Google to make them appear. With regards to some of my over simplifications. I feel that both as a novice as geology as well as being in a discussion with someone who admits to having little geology knowledge my purpose is to keep it as simple as possible. Hence the basin as a bowl in your backyard example. Even though in reality the situations are much more complicated, I feel that conceptually it it necessary to proceed at that level in the discussion.As for the peanut gallery. I was very interested in starting a thread like this to discuss the GD and primarily how accurate my descriptions of classical geology are. I was also very cautious to try to start it up prior to GD being finished for the same reasons as mentioned above. I may be far too early to make predictions about progress but Faith does seem to do her best work when she is not bombarded with responses.I would only ask that if this thread is going to continue in parallel that it be very carefully moderated to be ONLY a commentary and not a "safe place" to post rebuttals to Faith.It can also be discussed between Faith, myself, and other posters if there is a desire to hand the torch off to another opponent after a few more posts or so.

---

FOX has a pretty good system they have cooked up. 10 mil people watch the show on the network, FOX. Then 5 mil, different people, tune into FOX News to get outraged by it. I just hope that those good, God fearing people at FOX continue to battle those morally bankrupt people at FOX.
-- Lewis Black, The Daily Show

Now that Faith is on her way out maybe we could revive this topic. In particular, I would like to know everyone's opinion of how I did. I wish I could have found a better example of something like a buried river channel sooner but other than that what do you all think?Was there anything in particular that was factually incorrect about what I said.

---

FOX has a pretty good system they have cooked up. 10 mil people watch the show on the network, FOX. Then 5 mil, different people, tune into FOX News to get outraged by it. I just hope that those good, God fearing people at FOX continue to battle those morally bankrupt people at FOX.
-- Lewis Black, The Daily Show

I am not sure if much of anyone knew this more than I did after the deluge of human indecency that was the thread on Islam / Palestine. I didn't forget this when I decided to engage Faith in a calmer and more methodological manner. I simply made the decision that I was going to attempt to be the better half in hopes of gaining the upper ground in the discussion.Kill 'em with kindess is the phrase I believe.This is in stark contrast to the tennis game of headaches and insults that other threads she was involved in had decended into. In these there was no clear deliniation of her "stripes" as you call them because others seemed to be at least just as viscious.My whole goal was to present the argument in the way I would like it to be read by a curious reader. Even if your opponent is not progressing the the debate it does not mean that your attempts are futile. I was a lurker here for quite awhile before I decided to become an active member and I learned so much more from the calm destruction of YEC arguments then I ever did from the Jerry Springer style mud chucking threads.

---

FOX has a pretty good system they have cooked up. 10 mil people watch the show on the network, FOX. Then 5 mil, different people, tune into FOX News to get outraged by it. I just hope that those good, God fearing people at FOX continue to battle those morally bankrupt people at FOX.
-- Lewis Black, The Daily Show