Ben
Rather, if you have two systems that are physically similar enough to produce similar consciousnesses, I think we're obligated to call them the same
The two physically similar systems are called brains so, yes, we would call them the same.
The "I" is not reincarnated (the "I" would be tied irrevocably to the body), but consciousness seems not so fickle.
But this is not odd at all since consciousness, being a
function of the brain, will arise in any such structure. Thus, each new person has the potential for achieving consciousness as a result of possesing a brain. Reincarnation { the rebirth of a person in a new body after death} is not something I would apply here since you also make it clear that the "I" would not reincarnate.
Edited by sidelined, : No reason given.