umliak - I have had a look at your proposed topic and would make the following comments:
1) Too long - Not a single member is going to read all of those three posts; I gave up about 50% into the first one.
2) Too unclear - I'm not really sure what you are trying to say or debate. You need to identify 3-5 clear points about what you want to discuss and use those as a starting point. If you want to use the rest of the material you need to present it as the thread progresses.
I hope this is helpful.