If your whole point is to argue that scripture is inconsistent, you're wasting everybody's time. Nobody here is arguing that.
You're using one interpretation of scripture (bad guys go to hell) and mixing it with another interpretation of scripture (God is omniscient) to arrive at the conclusion that God is "unfair".
Using scripture in that way is just silly. You can come up with any conclusion you want if you pick and choose your references.
I was hoping this thread would be more than just schoolboys doing their Logic 101 exercises.
“Faith moves mountains, but only knowledge moves them to the right place” -- Joseph Goebbels