Tal writes:
quote:
Inactive Reserve time counts. For instance: When I first joined the Army in 96 I signed a 3 year contract to serve in the Infantry. In the Army, you sign on to serve 8 years, nomatter what your active duty contract says. When you finish your active duty obligation you are discharged and placed into the Inactive Reserve component. In my case, I could be called back to Active Duty at anytime in the next 5 years. I went back to Active Duty 3 years later. My time in service was then 6 years, even though 3 had been spent off active duty. So for pay purposes I was paid for having 6 years time in service instead of 3. The down side to that is I have to serve 23 years to retire, or 20 years Active Federal Service.
Hmmmmm, much of this doesn't sound right to me. I was in the IRR but only a few months ago. When you sign up for four years, you are actually obligated, by contractual agreement, to serve eight. However, after your initial four years as an active duty member or as a reservist, you can get out.
In the IRR you live life like a civilian in every way. However, until your contract ends, they can activate you dependent upon the need. In fact, I was activated by the Navy, however, unbeknownst to my command, they had signed a conditional release to allow me to join active duty USCG and, therefore, didn't belong to the USN any longer.
But you get no money or no benefits while in the IRR, nor does that remaining four year time accrue towards retirement should you decide to come back. I know because I was out of the military for three years and decided to come back.
I lost two ranks and none of that time in the IRR applies on my DD-214.
(Mind you, I'm 30 now and retirement is 15 years away. Doh!)
The problem with this as a rebuttal is that we were talking about the payroll report, which means we were talking in terms of pay purposes; so even including Inactive Reserve service, Bush only met 5 years and 4 months of his 6 year committment.
As stated above, IRR time does not count as military time. Its only there as a contractual agreement,
in the event, type deal...
Yes, Inactive Reserve service counts. Even including that, Bush failed to meet his commitment by 8 months. You still haven't supported your claim that Bush met his service committment.
I really haven't been following the argument, so I can't really speak on the matter too much. But I know this. Just being alive and in the IRR ensures that you meet the required time. If you joined February 28, 2000-- you have to serve as a regular reservist or active duty member until February 28, 2004. However, you are still under contractual agreement until February 28, 2008. The thing is, you don't have to do anything except respond to an email so they have your contact info updated. I don't see how Bush could not have met his contractual agreement simply because he was alive.
Edited by nemesis_juggernaut, : edit to add for further clarification
"It is better to shun the bait, than struggle in the snare." -Ravi Zacharias