In this and other forums, when athiesm is discussed, theists often use the phrase "choose to believe" or "choose not to believe", usually with reference to their god.
I find these phrases puzzling. I would suppose that one believes a proposition (or not) when one encounters satisfactory evidence for its truth (or falsity). How can one choose to believe something, or to disbelieve it? Can one choose to believe something one knows is false?
An example:
Suppose you are standing by a marsh, and you see a moose (it's hard to mistake a moose!). Could you disbelieve in the presence of the moose by any effort of will whatever?
Suppose you are sitting in a bar in town and your friend tells you there is a moose in that swamp right then. You know that neither you nor your friend have any way of knowing if a moose is there or not. How could you believe that either it is there, or not, by any effort of will?
Something one can decide to do is to profess a belief, regardless of whether one holds the belief or not. Do some religious people confuse holding a belief and professing one?
Edited by Woodsy, : grammar correction
Replies to this message: |
| Message 3 by Chiroptera, posted 04-03-2007 4:42 PM | | Woodsy has not replied |
| Message 4 by New Cat's Eye, posted 04-03-2007 4:43 PM | | Woodsy has replied |
| Message 6 by Dr Adequate, posted 04-03-2007 5:03 PM | | Woodsy has not replied |
| Message 9 by jar, posted 04-03-2007 5:26 PM | | Woodsy has replied |
| Message 10 by Stile, posted 04-03-2007 6:14 PM | | Woodsy has not replied |
| Message 11 by Larni, posted 04-04-2007 3:52 AM | | Woodsy has not replied |
| Message 12 by macaroniandcheese, posted 04-04-2007 4:23 AM | | Woodsy has not replied |
| Message 16 by Utopia, posted 04-04-2007 12:51 PM | | Woodsy has not replied |
| Message 17 by anastasia, posted 04-04-2007 12:56 PM | | Woodsy has not replied |
| Message 36 by ikabod, posted 04-26-2007 8:02 AM | | Woodsy has not replied |
| Message 57 by Raphael, posted 01-20-2014 12:41 PM | | Woodsy has not replied |